The CMS Network VIPs
Politics • Music • Comedy
EVANESCENCE ACCUSED OF LIFTING A METAL RIFF — AND THE INTERNET IS LOSING IT
The latest riff controversy has metal fans fighting over where inspiration ends and copying begins.
post photo preview
EVANESCENCE ACCUSED OF LIFTING A METAL RIFF — AND THE INTERNET IS LOSING IT

The second metal fans heard the comparison, the reaction was immediate: “There’s no way that’s a coincidence.” And honestly? This is exactly the kind of controversy modern metal keeps pretending doesn’t exist.

Need something loud while the comment war explodes? Metallica - The Broadcast Collection 1988-1994 - https://amzn.to/4phEFBg

YouTuber and guitarist Ola Englund just dropped a video titled “EVANESCENCE STOLE MY RIFF...” and the internet instantly did what the internet always does — picked sides before the first chorus even finished playing.

Here’s the reality: whether you think the riff was “stolen” or not almost doesn’t matter anymore. The bigger issue is that fans immediately recognized the similarity, and that alone is enough to ignite another massive debate about originality in heavy music.

Englund compared a riff from his own music to a riff used by Evanescence, and the resemblance was close enough to send fans spiraling into full detective mode. Some listeners are convinced the similarities are impossible to ignore. Others are calling the entire thing overblown because, according to them, “every riff has already been written.”

That excuse is getting old.

Metal fans love to scream that originality still matters, but the second someone points out a suspiciously familiar riff, suddenly everybody becomes a music theory professor explaining why nothing belongs to anyone anymore.

And that’s exactly why this story exploded.

Ola Englund didn’t come across as somebody launching a scorched-earth attack. In fact, his tone was more disbelief than outrage. But ironically, that may have made the controversy even bigger. Fans interpreted the calm reaction as credibility instead of clout-chasing.

Meanwhile, Evanescence fans immediately pushed back, arguing the riff pattern is common in metal and accusing critics of manufacturing drama out of normal songwriting similarities.

But here’s what those defenders are missing: perception matters.

Once listeners hear two riffs side-by-side and can’t unhear the similarity, the damage is already done. That becomes the story. Not intent. Not legality. Not technicalities.

And this keeps happening in rock and metal because bands are drawing from the same influences, same scales, same rhythmic approaches, and increasingly the same streamlined songwriting formulas.

That’s the uncomfortable conversation nobody wants to have.

Modern heavy music is starting to sound dangerously recycled.

Not all of it. But enough of it.

The real reason this controversy hit so hard is because fans are exhausted by safe, algorithm-friendly songwriting disguised as originality. When a riff instantly reminds people of another song, audiences don’t shrug anymore — they pounce.

And to be fair, metal fans have always treated riffs like sacred property. A legendary riff can define an entire career. So when similarities appear, people react emotionally, not academically.

That emotional reaction is exactly what’s fueling this fire.

Midway through the backlash, another predictable divide emerged:

  1. The “all riffs are recycled” crowd
  2. The “Evanescence copied it” crowd
  3. The “this is free publicity” crowd

And honestly, all three sides probably have a point.

But the biggest winner here may actually be Ola Englund himself. The video exploded because it tapped directly into a fear metal fans constantly have but rarely admit openly: what if the genre is running out of truly unforgettable ideas?

That question hits harder than the actual riff comparison.

Because once fans start believing modern metal is creatively cannibalizing itself, every new release gets scrutinized harder.

Every riff becomes suspect.

Every similarity becomes ammunition.

And no band — not even one as established as Evanescence — is immune from that backlash anymore.

One thing is certain: this conversation isn’t dying quickly. The comments are flooded with fans dissecting riffs, comparing timestamps, arguing music theory, and fighting over whether inspiration crossed the line into imitation.

Which means the controversy already achieved escape velocity.

Now the bigger question becomes what happens next.

Does Evanescence ignore the noise entirely?

Does the debate disappear in 48 hours like most internet outrage?

Or does this become another long-running example fans point to every time a suspiciously familiar riff appears in a major release?

Because in today’s metal scene, perception spreads faster than facts.

And once the internet labels something “copied,” good luck putting that fire out.

For more uncensored coverage, bonus episodes of THE CLASSIC METAL SHOW, early releases of CHRIS AKIN PRESENTS, giveaways, exclusives, and the best hard rock and metal community online, join now at https://classicmetalshow.locals.com

POLL

Did Evanescence cross the line with this riff controversy?

  • Yes — the similarity is way too obvious to ignore
  • No — metal riffs overlap constantly and fans are overreacting
  • Modern metal is so recycled now this was inevitable
community logo
Join the The CMS Network VIPs Community
To read more articles like this, sign up and join my community today
0
What else you may like…
Videos
Podcasts
Posts
Articles
Did SickSense Just Become A Completely Different Band?

SickSense isn’t exactly interested in staying in its lane—and the new Funerals EP makes that painfully obvious.

Vicky Psarakis opens up about the band’s darker musical direction, the surprisingly personal story behind A Moment of Violence, and why chasing whatever happens to be commercially popular can be a fast track to sounding like everybody else.

Then the conversation gets downright nasty when AI music enters the picture. Suno, Spotify, musicians skipping the hard work, endless AI-generated albums and the question nobody seems to want to answer: what happens to music when the humans stop being necessary?

Add a new North American tour and a completely DIY approach to keeping the band alive, and this interview goes a hell of a lot deeper than simply talking about a new EP.

Watch commercial free and without delayed publishing by becoming a CMS VIP at https://classicmetalshow.locals.com

All comments are merely the opinions of the people speaking them, are for comical ...

00:25:59
Does Asia Still Sound Like Asia? Harry Whitley Talks Indigo!

Walking into Asia as the new vocalist means stepping directly into the crosshairs of fans who know every note, every lyric and every inflection.

Harry Whitley doesn't shy away from that pressure. He talks about the John Wetton comparison, the challenge of performing the classic songs, and what changed when he finally got the chance to help create brand-new Asia music with Geoff Downes.

Then there's Indigo — the album that puts his own stamp on the band and forces the obvious question: can a new era of Asia actually satisfy fans who grew up with the classics?

Harry also gets into working with some seriously intimidating musicians, the band's chemistry behind the scenes, touring plans, fan reaction and why buying the music still matters in the streaming era.

There's a lot more going on here than just another new album interview.

Watch commercial free and without delayed publishing by becoming a CMS VIP at https://classicmetalshow.locals.com

All comments are merely the opinions of...

00:28:38
Why Did This Rocker Really Have A Meltdown In Japan? (2018 Archive)

When classic rock frontmen drop their guard, the real stories finally come spilling out. From the truth behind high-stakes reunion tours and backstage meltdowns to what really goes on when multi-million dollar bands hit the road, nothing is off-limits. Get ready for an unfiltered look at arena rock ego, ridiculous rider demands, and the shocking reality of why your favorite line-ups just can't stay together. You think you know the whole story behind the rock headlines? Think again.

GET DOKKEN'S THE ELEKTRA YEARS ON VINYL HERE: https://amzn.to/4heoMe1

Watch commercial free and without delayed publishing by becoming a CMS VIP at https://classicmetalshow.locals.com

GET ALL THE BEST CMS MERCH HERE: https://classicmetalshow.creator-spring.com/

All comments are merely the opinions of the people speaking them, are for comical performance, and are in no way stated as factual.

01:15:58
DEAD ARTIST LAWSUITS & AIRPLANE SEAT SQUATTERS! (Audio)

Why is everyone still suing Michael Jackson's estate? Neeley and Chris are giving their honest take on the skepticism surrounding the latest legal battle and reviewing the trailer for the upcoming MICHAEL biopic. We're also talking about the tragedy of the woman who fell off the cruise ship and the infuriating new trend of "seat squatting" on planes. Finally, CMS Producer Weezie honors our lost friend, Bob Nalbandian. Share and follow for the metal-fueled truth! Get commercial-free episodes by joining Rumble Premium at https://rumble.com/premium. Hail and Kill! Join the rebellion!

Sponsor: SPONSOR: The CMS Hail and Snore Pillow - https://classicmetalshow.creator-spring.com/listing/hail-and-snore-pillow

Get all your favorite CMS Merchandise from our online store: https://classicmetalshow.creator-spring.com/

BUY CHRIS AKIN'S BEST BOOKS HERE:

Call Me Chris by Chris Akin - https://amzn.to/44TDIZ4 Little Victories by Chris Akin - https://amzn.to/43A143y ...AND OTHER THINGS I SHOULD NOT SAY... By ...

DEAD ARTIST LAWSUITS & AIRPLANE SEAT SQUATTERS! (Audio)
Agnostic Front BASSIST on DMC & Their Bold New Sound! (Audio)

Seriously, how do you keep your music fresh when you're a band with a decades-long history? It's tough! Chris chats with Agnostic Front bassist Mike Gallo about their latest, ECHOES OF ETERNITY. They talk about the killer sound improvements, what it was like working with a legend like DMC for the first time, and the guts it takes to try new things as a legacy act. Don't just listen—hit that share button, follow us, and subscribe to Rumble Premium for more! Hail and Kill! Join the rebellion!

SPONSOR: The Classic Metal Show Stickers - https://classicmetalshow.creator-spring.com/listing/classic-metal-show-stickers

Get all your favorite CMS Merchandise from our online store: https://classicmetalshow.creator-spring.com/

BUY CHRIS AKIN'S BEST BOOKS HERE:

Call Me Chris by Chris Akin - https://amzn.to/44TDIZ4
Little Victories by Chris Akin - https://amzn.to/43A143y
...AND OTHER THINGS I SHOULD NOT SAY... By Chris Akin - https://amzn.to/3SRP3Bq

Want more? Get commercial-free episodes, early ...

Agnostic Front BASSIST on DMC & Their Bold New Sound! (Audio)
LEMMY SMASHES MIXING BOARD! KING DIAMOND'S $26K HANDOUT! (Audio)

What’s crazier: Lemmy destroying a multi-million dollar mixing board with a cheeseburger, or King Diamond getting $26,000 a year from his government just for being an artist? Neeley and Chris tackle these wild metal stories! We also review George Lynch's new single, which he released after admitting he totally lied about retiring. Hint: the guys are NOT impressed. Plus, check out the insane guitar talent from a young private school student. Like, follow, and share this video! Get commercial-free episodes and more by joining Rumble Premium at https://rumble.com/premium. Hail and Kill! Join the rebellion!

Sponsor: SPONSOR: Def Leppard - PYROMANIA 40TH ANNIVERSARY BOX SET - https://amzn.to/46AhFaB

Get all your favorite CMS Merchandise from our online store: https://classicmetalshow.creator-spring.com/

BUY CHRIS AKIN'S BEST BOOKS HERE:

Call Me Chris by Chris Akin - https://amzn.to/44TDIZ4 Little Victories by Chris Akin - https://amzn.to/43A143y ...AND OTHER THINGS I SHOULD NOT SAY... By Chris ...

LEMMY SMASHES MIXING BOARD! KING DIAMOND'S $26K HANDOUT! (Audio)

Metal Monday Album Battle. Savatage: Hall of the Mountain King vs. Gutter Ballet. One is the heavy breakthrough, the other is the bigger, more theatrical record that pointed toward everything they did next. Jon and Criss Oliva at their best either way. Which one do you reach for, and when did you first discover this band? A lot of people found them late. Tell us how you got there.

post photo preview

When Slayer becomes the voice of reason......LA show delayed due to fans destroying venue.

Sunday Metal Memories. Take us back to the first metal album you ever bought with your own money. What was it? Where'd you buy it: the mall, a mom-and-pop record store, a department store, a mail-order club? How old were you, and did your parents freak out when they saw the cover? Tell the whole story. These are the threads that make this community what it is. If you like hanging out here, CMS VIP on Locals is where the full uncensored episodes live.

post photo preview
post photo preview
HAIL & REKINDLE: The Week In CMS Roundup November-7 – November-13

Hail and Kill! Skid Row put a new singer in the firing line, Aerosmith gave everybody another farewell to argue about, and Triumph, Deep Purple and Cheap Trick dragged the retirement question back onto the stage. Meanwhile, Neeley and Chris opened the vault on their own questionable history, and CHRIS AKIN PRESENTS got into what happens when musicians insist on doing things their own way. Here’s the week in CMS.

THE CLASSIC METAL SHOW

Did Neeley and Chris Reveal Too Much About Their Past?

Chris and Neeley discuss personal history, backstage arguments, relationships, Halloween traditions, aging and on-air confrontations.

Watch the scheduled public release: https://classicmetalshow.locals.com/post/8296346/did-neeley-and-chris-reveal-too-much-about-their-past

Join CMS VIP for early, commercial-free uncensored episodes and THE CUT: https://classicmetalshow.locals.com

https://classicmetalshow.locals.com/post/8296346/did-neeley-and-chris-reveal-too-much-about-their-past

Did Skid Row Blow Their New Singer's Debut?

Skid Row vocalist Justin Sargent's introduction and song choice; Quiet Riot, W.A.S.P., John Bush and Anthrax, Joey Belladonna, Grindmother and Crystal Lake.

Watch the scheduled public release: https://classicmetalshow.locals.com/post/8296375/did-skid-row-blow-their-new-singers-debut

Join CMS VIP for early, commercial-free uncensored episodes and THE CUT: https://classicmetalshow.locals.com

https://classicmetalshow.locals.com/post/8296375/did-skid-row-blow-their-new-singers-debut

Should Triumph, Deep Purple & Cheap Trick Finally Retire?

Triumph cancellation, Deep Purple singer Ian Gillan's health/aging discussion, Cheap Trick guitarist Rick Nielsen seated onstage; when classic bands should retire.

Watch the scheduled public release: https://classicmetalshow.locals.com/post/8296428/should-triumph-deep-purple-cheap-trick-finally-retire

Join CMS VIP for early, commercial-free uncensored episodes and THE CUT: https://classicmetalshow.locals.com

https://classicmetalshow.locals.com/post/8296428/should-triumph-deep-purple-cheap-trick-finally-retire

Was Aerosmith's Final Farewell Just Another Cash Grab?

Aerosmith Hollywood Bowl farewell, guest musicians, Joey Kramer's appearance, Steven Tyler's performance and speculation about the band's future.

Watch the scheduled public release: https://classicmetalshow.locals.com/post/8296473/was-aerosmiths-final-farewell-just-another-cash-grab

Join CMS VIP for early, commercial-free uncensored episodes and THE CUT: https://classicmetalshow.locals.com

https://classicmetalshow.locals.com/post/8296473/was-aerosmiths-final-farewell-just-another-cash-grab

THE CUT

FAREWELL? BULLSHIT!

THE CUT is for paid CMS VIPs only. Join at https://classicmetalshow.locals.com for the members-only episode.

https://classicmetalshow.locals.com/post/8311798/is-journeys-farewell-a-cash-grab-plus-russell-brand-and-more-the-cut-11-7-26

CHRIS AKIN PRESENTS

Can Scardust Break Metal's Rules? Noa Gruman Talks Symphony, Sabaton & Hellscore

What happens when progressive metal collides with pop music, orchestras and a choir? Chris Akin interviews SCARDUST vocalist Noa Gruman about Souls, the band's cover of Symphony featuring Mia Asano, HELLSCORE, collaborations with Sabaton and others, future touring, and independent metal economics.

CMS merchandise: https://classicmetalshow.creator-spring.com/
SCARDUST: https://scardust.co

Join CMS VIP on Locals for advance, commercial-free and uncensored releases, early CAP interviews and exclusive content: https://classicmetalshow.locals.com

NOTE: The views expressed are opinions of the hosts and guests. Research claims independently.

https://classicmetalshow.locals.com/post/8283441/can-scardust-break-metals-rules-noa-gruman-talks-symphony-sabaton-hellscore

Can Phil Soussan Reinvent Himself With Cosmo Fighter?

Former Ozzy Osbourne bassist Phil Soussan joins Chris Akin on CHRIS AKIN PRESENTS to discuss collaborating with William Shatner, the Riot Fest experience, Tony Iommi's involvement, and his COSMO FIGHTER solo project. Phil explains taking control of songwriting, instrumentation, vocals, mixing and mastering; why he is releasing three four-song EPs rather than one album; and the realities of streaming revenue, technology, artistic freedom and supporting musicians.

PHIL SOUSSAN — VIBRATE: https://amzn.to/3TV5QYE

Join CMS VIP on Locals for early commercial-free and uncensored episodes, advance CHRIS AKIN PRESENTS interviews, THE CUT, CHAT AND KILL, giveaways and exclusive content: https://classicmetalshow.locals.com

NOTE: Views expressed by hosts and guests are opinions, not independently established facts. Do your own research.

https://classicmetalshow.locals.com/post/8283485/can-phil-soussan-reinvent-himself-with-cosmo-fighter

THE SETH WILLIAMS SHOW

Has Outrage Over Comedians Finally Killed Stand-Up Comedy?

Seth and Chris take on the outrage surrounding stand-up comedy, from Dave Chappelle and Shane Gillis to viral clips and the consequences of deplatforming. Can comedians still test material in a club without a phone recording turning it into the next online firestorm?

https://classicmetalshow.locals.com/upost/8318869/has-outrage-over-comedians-finally-killed-stand-up-comedy

GET JIM FLORENTINE’S JERSEY TRASH HERE: https://link.amazon/B0f8KOslD
GET DAVE LANDAU’S PARTY OF ONE - A FUZZY MEMOIR HERE: https://link.amazon/B02O9stwh

KEEP THE SHOW ALIVE. GET THE WHOLE DAMN THING.

Join CMS VIP on Locals at https://classicmetalshow.locals.com for advance Sunday releases, commercial-free and uncensored VIP episodes, THE CUT, early CHRIS AKIN PRESENTS interviews, CHAT AND KILL during the live show, giveaways, and exclusive members-only posts from Chris and Neeley.

Watch The Classic Metal Show live every Saturday from 9pm to 3am Eastern time at www.rumble.com/c/cms

Watch The Seth Williams Show live every Wednesday from 4pm to 5pm Eastern Time at www.rumble.com/c/tsws

Get new editions of CHRIS AKIN PRESENTS every Saturday and Sunday at www.rumble.com/c/cms

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Read full Article
post photo preview
Dangerous Toys' Jason McMaster Talks Rock History, Reissues & Metal's Biggest Bands!

Dangerous Toys frontman Jason McMaster joins Chris Akin and Neeley LIVE on THE CLASSIC METAL SHOW for an extended interview packed with hard rock history, behind-the-scenes stories, and the kind of music business conversation you won't get from a typical promotional interview!

WATCH THE VIDEO VERSION HERE:

McMaster discusses the deluxe reissue of Dangerous Toys' legendary debut album, the rare recordings and archival material that went into the release, and why the record deserved another shot. He also looks back at his decision to leave Watchtower, the early days of Dangerous Toys, and the challenges of moving between progressive metal and straight-ahead hard rock.

Plus, Jason reveals what it's like getting the call to step in for major metal bands, including Accept, Armored Saint, and Quiet Riot. How do you prepare to sing another legendary frontman's material? And what happens when you're suddenly sharing the stage with musicians you've admired for decades?

But the interview is only part of the insanity!

Chris and Neeley also tackle the increasingly ridiculous state of the music industry, including Spotify, Universal Music, and the growing influence of artificial intelligence. Are record companies finally turning music into a disposable product that anyone can manipulate? Is the actual artist becoming irrelevant?

The guys also get into the latest rock and metal discussions, audience reactions to Plush, the realities of modern music fandom, and the usual assortment of arguments, sarcasm, and completely unpredictable conversations that make THE CLASSIC METAL SHOW what it is.

No corporate-approved talking points. No fake enthusiasm. Just real conversations about hard rock, heavy metal, and whatever else pisses these two off!

SUPPORT THE CLASSIC METAL SHOW!

Get the complete uncensored, commercial-free CMS experience, including exclusive THE CUT segments and additional VIP content!

LOCALS VIP: https://classicmetalshow.locals.com

SUBSTACK: https://cmspn.substack.com

SUPPORT THE SHOW ON AMAZON!

PLUSH – MASS HYSTERIA: https://link.amazon/B0dUUrIqe

L.A. GUNS – COCKED AND LOADED: https://link.amazon/B05s4m4ey

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

WARNING: This show contains explicit language, adult humor, and potentially offensive opinions intended for mature audiences.

DISCLAIMER: Everything expressed on THE CLASSIC METAL SHOW represents the opinions of the hosts and guests. Commentary should not automatically be interpreted as established fact. Do your own research.

#DangerousToys #JasonMcMaster #TheClassicMetalShow #ChrisAkin #HardRock #HeavyMetal

Read full Article
post photo preview
Can Molly Hatchet Survive Without Its Original Members? Bobby Ingram Speaks!
Sixteen years without a new studio album. No original members remaining. And Molly Hatchet is STILL going. How?

Sixteen years without a new studio album. No original members remaining. And Molly Hatchet is STILL going. How?

Watch the full interview here:

placeholder

Get Molly Hatchet’s LOST HORIZON here on vinyl! https://amzn.to/4zijjJz

Bobby Ingram joins Chris Akin on CHRIS AKIN PRESENTS for a revealing conversation about the past, present, and future of one of Southern rock’s most recognizable names.

With LOST HORIZON arriving November 27, Bobby explains why the band spent years creating its latest record and how recording at the legendary Abbey Road Studios became an unforgettable experience.

But the conversation gets especially interesting when Chris raises the argument that has followed Molly Hatchet for decades: Can a band still be the same band when none of its original members remain?

Bobby doesn’t dodge the question.

He discusses his relationship with Danny Joe Brown, the decisions that kept Molly Hatchet alive, the band’s trademark, and what he believes the future should look like.

Plus, discover how new vocalist Parker Lee entered the picture, why Bobby compares him to a young Danny Joe Brown, and the message behind LOST HORIZON.

**Is preserving the music more important than preserving the original lineup?**

Watch the complete interview and join the discussion.

Get commercial free versions of our episodes, advance releases and exclusive content by subscribing to Rumble Premium! https://rumble.com/premium

NOTE: Everything said here, and on every episode of all of our shows, are 100% the opinions of the hosts. Nothing is stated as fact. Do your own research to see if their opinions are true or not.

Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals