Duff McKagan says Velvet Revolver was falling apart on its last tour. Was it the last great hard-rock supergroup, and could it have been saved?

Sources: Blabbermouth, transcribing Duff's new interview on the Finding Your Summit podcast with Mark Pattison; chart and Grammy facts from Rolling Stone and Loudwire.

June 2004. Three guys from Guns N' Roses, the singer from Stone Temple Pilots, and a guitarist most people had never heard of put out a debut album, and it knocks Usher off No. 1 on the Billboard 200. A hard rock band. In 2004. Velvet Revolver should have been the band that carried the torch for the next twenty years. Instead they were done in four. This week Duff McKagan finally told us what it looked like from the inside, and it isn't pretty.

🎸 Spin it again: Velvet Revolver's Contraband on vinyl → https://amzn.to/4rZKDsW

October 15, 2026

One of the biggest voices in symphonic metal is officially moving on, and NIGHTWISH fans are once again facing a question that has followed the band for decades: How many times can you replace the singer before the identity of the band changes forever?

NIGHTWISH has announced that it has parted ways with longtime vocalist Floor Jansen, ending a musical partnership that began in 2012 and produced three studio albums. The separation comes as the Finnish metal veterans celebrate their 30th anniversary, making the timing particularly surprising.

According to the band's announcement, the decision was mutual, with both parties determining that their individual musical ambitions would be better served by moving in different directions.

But while the official announcement presents an amicable separation, it leaves one enormous question unanswered: Why now?

ANOTHER CHAPTER CLOSES FOR NIGHTWISH

When Floor Jansen first stepped onto the stage with NIGHTWISH in October 2012, she was entering a situation that could have overwhelmed almost any vocalist.

Original singer Tarja Turunen had departed in 2005, and her replacement, Anette Olzon, had just exited the band. NIGHTWISH was once again facing uncertainty surrounding one of its most recognizable musical elements.

Jansen, already respected for her work with AFTER FOREVER and REVAMP, proved capable of handling the band's demanding catalog. Her combination of power, range, and commanding stage presence helped establish a new era for NIGHTWISH.

She officially joined the group in 2013 and went on to record three studio albums:

• Endless Forms Most Beautiful (2015)

• Human. :II: Nature. (2020)

• Yesterwynde (2024)

For more than a decade, Jansen became the voice associated with NIGHTWISH for an entire generation of fans.

Now that era is over.

THE BAND ISN'T STOPPING

Despite losing its third lead vocalist, NIGHTWISH has made one thing clear: The band intends to continue.

The group confirmed plans to enter the recording studio in 2027 to begin work on another album, signaling that the departure will not bring its 30-year history to an end.

However, NIGHTWISH has not announced a replacement singer or revealed who will handle vocal duties on the upcoming recording.

That creates an intriguing situation for a band whose history has already been defined by major changes behind the microphone.

With each previous transition, NIGHTWISH faced intense comparisons between vocalists, competing fan loyalties, and debates about which version of the group represented its definitive sound.

Now the process appears ready to begin all over again.

And this time, the departing singer spent nearly 14 years helping define the band's modern identity.

FLOOR JANSEN IS MOVING FORWARD

For Jansen, the departure comes as her solo career is gaining momentum.

The singer has confirmed that she will now devote her full attention to her own music, including her second solo album, Hytress, scheduled for January 15, 2027, and an accompanying tour.

Her first solo album, Paragon, arrived in 2023 and demonstrated that she could establish a musical identity outside NIGHTWISH.

In addressing the separation, Jansen acknowledged that the decision was difficult but expressed optimism about the next phase of her career.

Rather than stepping away from music, she appears ready to make her solo work her primary creative focus.

For fans who have followed her since the AFTER FOREVER days, the opportunity to hear Jansen pursue her own artistic direction without the expectations attached to NIGHTWISH could prove especially interesting.

CAN NIGHTWISH REPLACE ANOTHER DEFINING VOICE?

The larger question concerns NIGHTWISH itself.

There is no denying that keyboardist and songwriter Tuomas Holopainen has remained the central creative force behind the band's music. His compositions, arrangements, and artistic vision have provided continuity through decades of lineup changes.

But singers are different.

For many listeners, the vocalist is the most immediately recognizable part of a band's sound.

Tarja Turunen brought an operatic identity that helped establish NIGHTWISH internationally. Anette Olzon introduced a different vocal approach, and Floor Jansen brought another distinctive combination of theatrical delivery and metal power.

Each singer represented a different chapter.

Each developed a loyal following.

And each departure forced fans to reconsider what NIGHTWISH was supposed to sound like.

The band has already demonstrated that it can survive significant personnel changes. Whether it can successfully reinvent itself for a fourth vocal era remains an open question.

THE TIMING MAKES THIS EVEN MORE INTERESTING

NIGHTWISH has been away from live performances since 2023, having previously announced an indefinite break from touring.

The band released Yesterwynde in 2024 without undertaking a supporting concert tour.

Now, with its 30th anniversary underway and another studio album planned, the group finds itself preparing for its next chapter without the singer who helped define its last three records.

Neither side has publicly disclosed a detailed explanation of the circumstances behind the split beyond describing it as a mutual decision.

There is no confirmed replacement, no announced return to touring, and no indication of what musical direction the next NIGHTWISH album will take.

For now, fans are left with more questions than answers.

THE BIG QUESTION: IS NIGHTWISH STILL NIGHTWISH WITHOUT FLOOR JANSEN?

There is a larger debate here that goes well beyond one band.

At what point does a group become more of a musical institution than a collection of recognizable musicians?

NIGHTWISH has maintained its name and creative foundation through multiple major lineup changes. Yet each singer has left a distinct mark on the music and on the fans who discovered the band during that particular era.

Some listeners will undoubtedly welcome the possibility of another reinvention.

Others may see Jansen's departure as the end of the version of NIGHTWISH they connected with most strongly.

And still others may be more interested in what Floor Jansen can accomplish now that she is concentrating entirely on her solo career.

One thing is certain: 2027 is shaping up to be a defining year for both NIGHTWISH and Floor Jansen.

The band is preparing another album. Jansen is preparing her own release and tour. Both are moving forward, but separately.

After nearly 14 years together, one of symphonic metal's most recognizable partnerships has reached its conclusion.

Now it's your turn: Was Floor Jansen the best singer NIGHTWISH ever had? Can the band successfully replace her, or should it finally consider calling it a career?

Malmsteen admits he "probably should have" joined David Lee Roth's band in 1985. We ran the what-if.

Sources: Blabbermouth, quoting Yngwie's new interview with Eamon O'Neill of Eonmusic; also reported by BraveWords.

Picture it. 1986. David Lee Roth, freshly out of Van Halen, drops his first full solo album. You put on the record and the guy shredding next to Dave isn't Steve Vai. It's Yngwie J. Malmsteen, in the frilly shirt, with the scalloped Strat and a Paganini chip on his shoulder.

🎸 The album that almost had Yngwie on it: David Lee Roth's Eat 'Em and Smile, the 180g 35th Anniversary gatefold vinyl. A must-own for any 80s collection → https://amzn.to/4jjfCy0